06-15-2015, 10:05 AM
Well... actually I don't know if we are seeing things so diferently... Let me explain...
This would be the “good will act” I talked about. Juliette's reaction to that action would be able to stop the negative rolling ball.
You quote that the sequense depends on Juliete's reaction. That is exactly my point point. The things the will happend after dependes on how they are reacting now to what happend before.
You have just explained how the characteres can react in a way that Rosalee and Juliette get close friends again.
The diference I see between our point of view is that you are framing a positive perspective where characteres would act in a positive way so they get close again. In your previwed future they would reverse the tendence of past actions and build a new light future (I am using those terms just to mark a difference with what I will wrote bellow).
In my term, I am framing a negative perspective where characteres would act in negative way so would get even more apart from each other. In my previewed future they would reinforce the dark tendence the 4th season ended. (I am using dark just to mark as diferent from the term light I used above).
Let me explain that I am not using a negative perspective because I believe this is the right one, or becuase your preview would not happend. I am using the negative perspective becuase I believe that to get to your preview (the light future) they will have to deal and by pass obstacles that, if they didn't, they would end up in my preview (the dark future).
Back to the subject to give an exemple. Rosalee can imagine that Juliette went back to the house to kill Nick and them go out to Europe to live with the royals. If Rosalee believes that, she would never go to the hospital. This is an obstacle to your light future perfectly possible based on how things happend in the end of seasson 4. But, Rosalee can also "want to know why", as you said, by passing the dark obstacle I have put above. That is also perfectly possible based in Rosalee's actions in all 4 seassons.
If we get only mine preview, we will lost the perspective that "... the show is about acceptance" as you comment in another post. But if we get only your preview, we will lost the perspective that the last season put a mine field between Rosalee/Monroe and Juliette. And this mine field must be by passed.
Actually, I think it would be very interesting to see how the show writers would build season 5 story to get them close again... How would they write characters actions to by pass the close past events in season 4.
(06-14-2015, 06:52 PM)Adriano Neres Rodrigues Wrote: I also know that things can be different if some of them stop the negative rolling ball and the other accept the, last call, “good will act”.
(06-15-2015, 08:41 AM)irukandji Wrote: Okay, here are my conclusions on the fourth season. Juliette did not leave with the royals as expected. She came back home. Focusing specifically Rosalee and Monroe, and knowing what I know of them from the fourth season, I think they would want to know why. I could see them going to the hospital to talk to her. They might even pursue the reasons why she acted the way she did at the spice shop.
This would be the “good will act” I talked about. Juliette's reaction to that action would be able to stop the negative rolling ball.
(06-15-2015, 08:41 AM)irukandji Wrote: Then, based on what Juliette tells them,
You quote that the sequense depends on Juliete's reaction. That is exactly my point point. The things the will happend after dependes on how they are reacting now to what happend before.
(06-15-2015, 08:41 AM)irukandji Wrote: I see Rosalee, specifically, taking 20 steps back and looking at what she could have done differently that day in the spice shop. Rosalee is a herbalist, but in her own way, she is also a scientist. She would no doubt question why she put her faith in a belief system rather than scientifically weighing the situation and coming up with facts based on her knowledge. She would question why she handled the situation so sloppily and if she was acting in Juliette’s best interests or her own.Just to point out. I based my argues in a cause efect chain reaction. So, I can perfectly see Rosalee doing this. But as you said, she should take "... 20 steps back". So, we have a dinamic that must be reverse.
(06-15-2015, 08:41 AM)irukandji Wrote: As for Juliette, her outcome depends upon what she tells Monroe and Rosalee. She may very well wish to remain a hexenbiest, but might ask for help in dealing with her symptoms. She might want to be a human again in which case a search begins for a cure. If she decides she wants to remain a hexenbiest and wants to remain in their company, then they all (not just Juliette) will have to work together to resolve their conflicts.
You have just explained how the characteres can react in a way that Rosalee and Juliette get close friends again.
The diference I see between our point of view is that you are framing a positive perspective where characteres would act in a positive way so they get close again. In your previwed future they would reverse the tendence of past actions and build a new light future (I am using those terms just to mark a difference with what I will wrote bellow).
In my term, I am framing a negative perspective where characteres would act in negative way so would get even more apart from each other. In my previewed future they would reinforce the dark tendence the 4th season ended. (I am using dark just to mark as diferent from the term light I used above).
Let me explain that I am not using a negative perspective because I believe this is the right one, or becuase your preview would not happend. I am using the negative perspective becuase I believe that to get to your preview (the light future) they will have to deal and by pass obstacles that, if they didn't, they would end up in my preview (the dark future).
Back to the subject to give an exemple. Rosalee can imagine that Juliette went back to the house to kill Nick and them go out to Europe to live with the royals. If Rosalee believes that, she would never go to the hospital. This is an obstacle to your light future perfectly possible based on how things happend in the end of seasson 4. But, Rosalee can also "want to know why", as you said, by passing the dark obstacle I have put above. That is also perfectly possible based in Rosalee's actions in all 4 seassons.
If we get only mine preview, we will lost the perspective that "... the show is about acceptance" as you comment in another post. But if we get only your preview, we will lost the perspective that the last season put a mine field between Rosalee/Monroe and Juliette. And this mine field must be by passed.
Actually, I think it would be very interesting to see how the show writers would build season 5 story to get them close again... How would they write characters actions to by pass the close past events in season 4.