10-02-2015, 08:00 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2015, 08:07 AM by Adriano Neres Rodrigues.)
(10-02-2015, 07:23 AM)irukandji Wrote:(10-02-2015, 06:17 AM)Adriano Neres Rodrigues Wrote:(10-02-2015, 06:03 AM)Lin S. Wrote:(10-02-2015, 05:19 AM)irukandji Wrote: I think we've discovered a major plothole here. The writers are stating that Adalind, under the guise of Juliette, became pregnant with Nick's baby. That could happen. She was using Juliette's DNA to make the spell work. The spell would have physically turned her into Juliette, all the way down to the uterus. The baby implanted there would have had Juliette' DNA and Nick's DNA because Adalind was physically Juliette at that point in time. Had she remained in the image of "Juliette", it would be plausible that she could carry the baby to term.
In theory, however, once the spell was broken, there should have been no pregnancy. The baby was conceived under a different form using different DNA. Once Adalind became Adalind by taking on her own form and DNA, the baby should have dissipated along with the spell. The writers are pulling a fast one here by talking about a pregnancy that could not have existed.
You are assuming that Adalind and Juliette do have different DNA. That they are two distinct different human beings. What if one is the light (Silverton) and one is the (dark) version of the same person?
I think this post has many questions that should be answered before we get to the : does Adelaind and Nick baby have Juliette DNA or Adelaind DNA?
This idea of Juliette and Adelaind being the same person like Hide and Jackill is one idea. The problem is that I remember seen Adelaind and Juliette at the same place more the once.
Another question I have never seeing answered here in the forum (the show didn't answer to)... Is: how deep had Adelaind turn into Juliette by the speel?
Irukandji is considering Adelaind changed deep into the DNA. This is a possibility. But she could have changed only externally, her appearance.... Internally considering internal organs and her DNA Adelaind could still be Adelaind. I guess (this is just a guess) the writers are following thus path simply because this explains Adelaind baby being Adelaind's and the writers don't need to explain how the DNA could have being magically changed. It is easier for them.
The point is.... We don't how powerful and deep was Adelaind transformation to consider that she was Juliette DNA when the baby was conceived. I think this is the first question to be answered.
So do you believe the transformation is merely an illusion? That Nick thinks he's seeing Juliette but it's Adalind the whole time?
Personally, I have no idea and that is why I think this deserves a more deep thinking and then a more complete answer. Sincerelly I would like the explanation was a little more complex. I really liked your theory of deep change going down to the DNA.
Unfortunately I think the writers, if they gave some official answer, it will be the easy one: it was just a ilussuion.
I suppose it because since they killed Juliette, I think they want to clean the story for season five so they can start new plots. Actually that is the promise: a restart in the series. Isn't it?
If they bring Juliette back, than I think the writers can use the deep Adelaind transformation to say the baby is Juliette's baby. This would create a lot of conflicts between Adelaind (the mother that carried the baby nine months), Juliette (the DNA mother) and Nick.
But at least until the beginning of the season five I don't see the writers following this path.