(06-27-2017, 08:38 AM)Hell Rell Wrote: I view most deleted scenes that were actually filmed as part of the show that they just cut for time. It would be different if they changed the scene by putting a different one in the show to replace it.
There was a scene from GOT season 2, when the show was still good, where Tyrion making Shae into Sansa's handmaiden made a lot more sense. It was easy to tell exactly where that scene would've been placed in the episode and it doesn't contradict anything we've seen. There were a few from OZ that also serve the same purpose. They only add more context to what we've already seen. It's kind of like an extended cut of the show.
A deleted scene of Nick saying he still loves Juliette and made a mistake with Adalind is a poor example. It would completely contradict everything we've seen. A good portion of the final season would have to be rewritten just to support this scene or go in a different direction once they decided to scrap it.
I certainly was not serious about that scene. I merely pointed out that deleted scenes can be interpreted in a number of ways. I can guarantee you that if there was a scene reflecting Nick's romantic feelings toward Juliette, the same argument would be used that I am using now. In short, if it didn't appear in the series, then it didn't happen.
The only exception I see to this argument is if a commentary is included with the dvd and that's why I asked the question. There's no arguing with a director who's talking about the scene and the reason for the deletion.
I have the complete X-files series with deleted scenes. There is no commentary with the scenes so it's impossible for me to tell why they were deleted.
The assumption that just because you can tell where a scene was deleted, so it must have been cut for time is not always correct. I have the deleted scenes and the commentary from the movie, From Hell. There are several deleted scenes which fit in perfectly with the story, but they were not deleted due to time constraints. They were deleted because they did not reflect the director's vision.
Directors are just like all of us. They can shoot a scene, but are free to change their minds at any time if the scene doesn't fit in with their vision.
The best way to frustrate a cyberbully is to ignore him.