01-28-2018, 09:10 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-28-2018, 09:19 AM by dicappatore.)
(01-28-2018, 06:22 AM)syscrash Wrote: Obviously Henry and decapitator you don't understand having an intellectual discussion. For one an intellectual discussion you from a theory and then provide facts that support that theory. In this type of discussion opinion and beliefs do not work. he is an example.
Quote:Adalind took Nicks powers beacuse she wanted Diania back plain and simple,There is a problem with that statement. Yes victor told her take Nick powers and she could see Diana. Problem is Victor did not have Diana. Even though the character thought he did. It becomes a false statement to argue in the definitive when we know it is a misleading fact.
You, want an intellectual conversation? How, you lack the intellect to be unable to separate us, the viewers from the characters. We are the voyeurs. we aren't able to participate. It becomes a false statement to us but not to the character Adalind. She is guided by what she believes not by what we see from behind the curtain.
Let me ask you, if you see a squad of soldiers in a war movie about to get ambushed, do you scream out "LOOK OUT" and expect them to react? If they don't, do you consider them idiots? I hope not. That is why, interjecting what we see, overhead, we can not criticize the character based on what we see. We have to separate what we see overall to what that character sees, which isn't the whole picture.
The movie "Patton" is based on an actual person and an actual war. When we see what he is planning and what his orders are, do you think those actual soldiers on the actual front lines knew what was going on like us, the viewers? I don't think so. All they knew, every time they moved out, most likely someone was going to shoot at them. The front line soldier wasn't in-the-know to what we know as the viewers. well, Mr.Intellectual, the same applies to this show, Capisce?
You got one or two contributors, on some of these threads claiming that Kelly was so stupid she walked into a trap with a baby girl in tow. How STUPID is that claim? How dumb is that statement? Do you really think, if Kelly knew what we knew, as viewers, she would have waltzed into that trap? Do you see how your reasoning SUCKS?
Quote:You also have a problem with the statement because nothing proves that she had to sleep with Nick to take his powers. We have no logical reason for the writers to use that method. From a story stand point It drives the story arc of the eventual breakup and Juliette's animosity towards Adalind.
Mr. intellectual, if we are not logical, to believe, to take away his Grimm, it shouldn't be to sleep with him? How does that reasoning support the whole show. If that isn't logical, by you? how is the rest of the show logical? Its is a fantasy show.
The writes can and chose to explain what they want. There is no wrong or right. There is only what they wrote. What they choose to apply to reality and what they choose to apply to fantasy is a decision made by what the creative team puts down on paper.
Quote:As for the rest of your paragraph you are arguing a point. I was describing a concept. To say hexenbiest are conniving does not mean that to be conniving makes you a hexenbiest. The same with your argument about Adadlind not being confrontational. I was showing how she was different. Pointing out the reason does not change the how. Comparing her to others also does not change the how she is different.
Also you keep mixing what she is with who she is. Think of it this way. the what she is determines how she does something. why she does something is based on who she is.
example helping others is a sign of who you are. Being a programmer and solving problems logically is because of what you are. Even though solving problems logically does not make you a programmer.
More laughable moments. You are the one doing exactly what you accuse others. The only one whom is confused here, it is YOU. You aren't able to separate what is fantasy and what is real, you know why? The whole frekin show is a fantasy. How are you able to apply logic to an illogical show? Do Grimms really exist to be able to claim that a Grimm can not get taken away by Hex by sleeping with him? There are people with the surname Grimm. That is as far as they exist.
You know you are OLD, when you see the Slide Ruler you used in college selling in an ANTIQUE SHOP!!