07-31-2020, 01:43 PM
(07-31-2020, 10:46 AM)irukandji Wrote: Tish wrote: I brought up Kelly spiriting Diana away to parts unknown with the help of Sean and Nick and the Scoobies. She trusted Kelly to keep them both safe...and Kelly took her daughter. That was a massive betrayal by the gang that set in motion all the stuff that happened latter.Uh...Adalind several times informs people that they took Diana. She accused Sean of that in the scene where Nick was informed that he was about to become a father. She also confronts Rosalee with that when she informs her that she's aware of the part that Rosalee played in the spiriting of her child away from her. Yes Sean authorizing it does put the stain of legality on it. So how about I change the wording to taking the baby from her. That is a betrayal because she trusts them to protect her and the baby -- and they instead decide to leave her high and dry -- and spirit off with her child.
That's true. Kelly and the gang kidnapping baby Diana can be looked at as a betrayal of Adalind's trust. But what I am saying is that is a matter of opinion. Not one of the characters confirmed it as a betrayal like Nick did to Eve when he confronted her about his mother. Some fans believe that it was not a kidnapping at all since Sean approved of the plan and he was Diana's father. Other fans have stated there was justification as Adalind and Sean would have been murdered if they were found protecting Diana. Even Adalind herself doesn't consider it a kidnapping and that could be because her original intent was to sell Diana to the royals, but then she changed the deal by demanding a hexenbiest spirit instead. She got her spirit but the royals did not get baby Diana. Adalind knew she was going to be pursued until they got what they believe was rightfully theirs by reason of fulfilling her demands.
Point blank -- people change their minds all the time -- do you know how many adoptions fall through because the birth mother changes her mind? So I don't hold a lot of validity to your argument that it doesn't count against the scoobies. It means nothing to the betrayal -- you can't say it's not a betrayal because she was originally going to do this. You have to base the betrayal on what actually happened -- which is she changed her mind and decided to keep her baby and Diana was taken from her without her permission (since legally custody hadn't been determined -- using U.S. law based in the state I reside in and having been through custody fights before -- both parents can chose to do something without the other parents permission -- but sending a child off with a complete stranger and having no idea where wouldn't not have been looked on very well in the eyes of the court for Sean...just saying).