10-21-2016, 10:33 AM
(10-20-2016, 08:55 PM)irukandji Wrote:(10-20-2016, 07:54 PM)syscrash Wrote: The difference between Juliette and the three you mentioned. Juliette is a hexenbiest 24/7 the others are not. If Juliette was only a hexenbiest when she woged. Then she would be Juliette possessed. Like Sean was. Nick as a zombie was no longer Nick. Wu is a split personality.
I can see the reasoning behind Adriano's statement that because Juliette is a hexenbiest, it doesn't mean she isn't Juliette just because she acquired a new id and is now called Eve. I asked the question because even though Nick, Wu and Renard are still known as Nick, Wu, and Renard, are they the same people they were before? In answer to that question, I would have to say no. Each of them, just like Juliette, has endured some chemical changes that have affected them.
The only difference with Juliette, is that she was beaten, brainwashed, and I believe magically forced into believing she is Eve. Juliette is now some detached self that resides within her. I do not for one minute believe this was her idea any more than it was her idea to hang with HW. As a side note, I am glad that creep Meisner died because he's to blame for that.
You got my point. Nick, Wu and Sean changed in the show. Nick changed because he became a grimm. He changed because he got new powers or he was influenced by magical/wesen powers (like the zombie effects or like the muse thing). But he was still Nick.
Sean changed because he decided to join Nick and protect himself from the royals and now he joins BC and is fighting Nick. He was affected by the Jack possession. But he was still Sean.
Wu also changed. He found out about wesen. Now he is a like cave-man-wesen. But he is trying to learn how to control this new Wu.
But none of those changes is enough to say that a character is dead and a new character rose from them. Why should I accept this about Juliette?
I am not complaining about the name changing. Trubel or Tereza is still the same person. She is still the same character, only using a different name. Nick went to German with a fake name. The same character using a new (fake) name. What I can’t accept is this all idea that Eve can’t be blamed for what Juliette did because she is Eve and Juliette was Juliette. Juliette and Eve is the same person. Just it.