12-22-2015, 12:19 PM
I have some problems with the character Eve.
First: The writers want us to simply accept Eve is a new character totally different from Juliette, but only with her memories. It doesn’t make sense. And think about it: Will they do this with Nick and the others? I mean… Will Nick (and the others) learn from the HW that “we transformed dead Juliette in a military weapon called Eve” and Nick (and the others) will answer only: Ok?
Second: Apparently Eve is a super powerful character. How will the writers create tension and interest if Eve can’t be killed, defeated or threatened (since she has no emotion)?
Third: If Eve has emotions, she is Juliette. If Eve has no emotion, she is simply a toy in HW hands. I think it doesn’t satisfy Juliette lovers and neither Juliette haters. I mean: Is Eve a person? If this is case, she must have emotions. If this is not the case, them she is a machine. (I remember Robocop with this plot... and he had emotions).
Fourth: Considering the statements above, my impression is something like the writers lying to us (Juliette is dead, now you have Eve) and expecting us to believe, even we knowing it is a lie.
I would be less critical if the writers bring her back as Juliette twin sister. It would be easier to accept.
Just to let it clear: My criticism is not about Juliette or the actress. It is about the plot line the writers created to bring them back. My opinion (I maybe be wrong) is that It is unbelievable.
First: The writers want us to simply accept Eve is a new character totally different from Juliette, but only with her memories. It doesn’t make sense. And think about it: Will they do this with Nick and the others? I mean… Will Nick (and the others) learn from the HW that “we transformed dead Juliette in a military weapon called Eve” and Nick (and the others) will answer only: Ok?
Second: Apparently Eve is a super powerful character. How will the writers create tension and interest if Eve can’t be killed, defeated or threatened (since she has no emotion)?
Third: If Eve has emotions, she is Juliette. If Eve has no emotion, she is simply a toy in HW hands. I think it doesn’t satisfy Juliette lovers and neither Juliette haters. I mean: Is Eve a person? If this is case, she must have emotions. If this is not the case, them she is a machine. (I remember Robocop with this plot... and he had emotions).
Fourth: Considering the statements above, my impression is something like the writers lying to us (Juliette is dead, now you have Eve) and expecting us to believe, even we knowing it is a lie.
I would be less critical if the writers bring her back as Juliette twin sister. It would be easier to accept.
Just to let it clear: My criticism is not about Juliette or the actress. It is about the plot line the writers created to bring them back. My opinion (I maybe be wrong) is that It is unbelievable.