12-24-2016, 07:29 PM
(12-24-2016, 01:01 PM)irukandji Wrote:Hi Iruk,(12-24-2016, 12:52 PM)New Guy Wrote: IMO, she does not have a mental disorder. She was confronted with situations that she did not like and reacted in a violent criminal manner. She did spend some time in jail for the bar fight, but has never faced any consequences for her other crimes. If she were brought to trial, the Multiple Personality defense would likely not hold water. What judge or jury would believe she is Eve and it was Juliette who did it. Get real!
N G
She doesn't have a mental disorder, New Guy. The disorder is a magical one, just like Renard's Ripper or Nick's zombie. They're all lame, I agree. But then I'm not writing the series.
The creators told us Juliette was dead and because the actions of Hexenette really don't reflect those of Juliette, I am inclined to agree.
Thanks for your comments.
I came across this Christian Times article:
http://christiantimes.com/article/grimm-.../56404.htm
There is brief mention of Eve by the EPs (G&K):
Quote:As for Eve's character, she showed signs of Juliette returning, and her feelings after being awakened might be further explored next season. "There's part of her that was dead, that she had killed, that they had killed," the EP explained. "Suddenly it was awakened. And because she's a Hexenbiest, it had a super effect. So we'll have to see what happens with the Eve side of her personality and now having all these feelings, which is going to include a lot of guilt. It'll be complex."We know G&K have teased about how the plot lines will move forward, but if in season 6 " . . . we'll have to see what happens with the Eve side of her personality and now having all these feelings, which is going to include a lot of guilt."
Will her "guilt" be about all the BC she tortured and killed in season 5? Will her "guilt" be about all the crap she put Nick through in the first four seasons? By the end of season 4 she had become pure villain and so homicidal that Nick told the Scoobies to "kill her." None of them protested his directive and IMO they agreed with him. I do not recall any of them in season 5 indicating a change in that position. IMO, they seem to accept FrankenEve as a killing machine that is of use in defending against BC, but still hold her accountable for all her vile acts.
From 5.18, "Good to the Bone":
Quote:Eve: You were in the tunnel, weren't you?FrankenEve is a killing machine. She threatened Adalind. Rosalee's reply and final "...If I was Juliette" makes it clear she views FrankenEve as the same mortal threat that Hexenette was. I wonder what FrankenEve would have done if instead Rosalee replied something like:
Rosalee: Uh, yeah. It wasn't because of you we didn't come out.
Eve: It was because of Adalind. She didn't know you were there. I sensed you; she didn't. She's out of practice, Rosalee. She won't be for long. [She starts to head for the exit]
Rosalee: You threatened her. You said if she did anything to Nick, you'd go after her.
Eve: You have a problem with that?
Rosalee: It's what I would have said...
[Eve leaves]
Rosalee: ...If I was Juliette.
Juliette, you tried to kill Adalind several times. If you go after her again it will be you with the problem.
Would she woge and attack Rosalee? Would she kill her?
N G