05-28-2013, 12:11 PM
(05-28-2013, 11:52 AM)Adriano Neres Rodrigues Wrote: . . . I believe it is safe to assume that the royal families . . .Here are some general points for deductive reasoning. You have the ability to assume anything. You also have the ability to believe any assumption. However, it is never safe to assume anything.
Speculation is always fine. It is simply putting forth possible theories to explain facts. However, as paraphrased from the great Sherlock Holmes, twisting facts to suit speculation though is not fine, and runs counter to deductive reasoning.
Alas, all I'm doing is showing that many of the facts of the Grimm universe are inconsistent. This could be explained that the facts (most of which involve hearsay) are unreliable. It could also be explained by the writers being careless.
In any case though, all I can do is show that the facts are inconsistent. Though, if I show the facts are inconsistent throughout the series, that would support that the writers are careless/dumb. Though, how "logical" is the writing is ultimately of little value to how much I actually enjoy the show.
So, whether Renard and Nick being in the same city is a coincidence or the result of an exterior force can be true, especially where we have so few facts.